Shelter Island Heights Motels - Cheap Motels in Shelter Island Heights NY

5 accommodations found from 5,000 sites

ASilver Sands Motel

Average Rating
4.5
5+ reviews
from 2 sources
Yahoo! Travel
4.5
4+ reviews
TravelPost.com
9.0
1+ reviews
  • Highlights: pool, room service, maid service, non… more
  • Location: Greenport, New York (1.7 miles from Shelter Island Heights)
  • rooms are pretty large w/ a separate sitting/eating area more on Yahoo! Travel
  • our room (which we passed on b/c we had a room w/ a great view) and they gave us yet another great discount more on Yahoo! Travel
Silver Sands Motel

Estimated Price: From $150

Silver Sands Motel
70930 Silvermere Rd
Greenport, NY 11944

BSilver Sands Motel & Beach Cottages

Average Rating
4.5
17+ reviews
from 1 sources
TripAdvisor
4.5
17+ reviews
  • very quiet forested location well off the main road with spacious grounds and a beautiful private beach on the shore of peconic more on TripAdvisor
  • kids loved it and we stayed for the rest of the holiday more on TripAdvisor

Estimated Price: From $200

Silver Sands Motel & Beach Cottages
PO Box 285
Greenport, NY 11944

CSunset Motel

Average Rating
4.0
8+ reviews
from 2 sources
CitySearch
3.5
2+ reviews
TripAdvisor
4.0
6+ reviews
  • rooms were spotless and the staff was extremely helpful and patient more on TripAdvisor
  • water with great views more on TripAdvisor

Estimated Price: From $177

Sunset Motel
62005 Route 48
Greenport, NY 11944

DSunset Motel

  • Highlights: kitchenette, refrigerator more
  • Location: Greenport, New York (1.3 miles from Shelter Island Heights)

Estimated Price: From $155

Sunset Motel
Route 48
Greenport, NY

ESouthold Beach Motel

Average Rating
4.5
2+ reviews
from 1 sources
TravelPost.com
9.5
2+ reviews
  • Highlights: cable television, kitchenette more
  • Location: Southold, New York (2.9 miles from Shelter Island Heights)
  • The location is great, in a cute town on the water. Plus, when you go to the public beach, you don't have to pay the $10 parking fee. Very friendly and helpful environment. The rooms were very clean and comfortable with full kitchens. I am very likely ... more on TravelPost.com
  • Its amazing how far from the city you can get in just a couple of hours. The motel is friendly and homey, a real family place. There's a nice shady yard for cook-outs in back, and a deck to look out over the beach in front. The four of us stayed in one room with space to spare, and the kitchenett... more on TravelPost.com
Southold Beach Motel

Estimated Price: From $150

Southold Beach Motel
53250 North Rd.
Southold, NY 11971