Shelter Island B&Bs - Best Shelter Island NY Bed and Breakfasts

6 accommodations found from 5,000 sites

ABartlett House Inn

Average Rating
4.5
20+ reviews
from 4 sources
BedAndBreakfast.com
5.0
2+ reviews
Yahoo! Travel
5.0
4+ reviews
tripadvisor
4.5
13+ reviews
  • Highlights: room service, maid service, non-smoki… more
  • Location: Greenport, New York (2.7 miles from Shelter Island)
  • bathroom was spotless and fresh and a special treat was finding two white terry bathrobes hanging in the closet more on Tripadvisor
  • great value for money more on Tripadvisor
Bartlett House Inn
Bartlett House Inn
503 Front Street
Greenport NY 11944, USA

Estimated Price: From $150

BHarbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast

Average Rating
3.5
10+ reviews
from 3 sources
BedAndBreakfast.com
4.0
1+ reviews
tripadvisor
3.5
7+ reviews
CitySearch
3.5
2+ reviews
  • location itself and the property are very beautiful and the pictures displayed on their website reflect what you will get more on Tripadvisor
  • only very minor thing I would inquire about if you are staying there is the bathroom more on Tripadvisor
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast
424 Fourth Street
Greenport NY 11944, USA

Estimated Price: From $145

CThe Morning Glory Bed and Breakfast

Average Rating
4.0
10+ reviews
from 3 sources
CitySearch
3.5
1+ reviews
tripadvisor
4.0
7+ reviews
BedAndBreakfast.com
5.0
2+ reviews
  • bampersentb is done in a very lovely, comfy and elegant country theme that is done in a cozy ambiance more on Tripadvisor
  • breakfasts are incredible, the rooms are immaculate and classy, not overly flowery more on Tripadvisor
The Morning Glory Bed and Breakfast
The Morning Glory Bed and Breakfast
912 Main Street
Greenport NY 11944, USA

Estimated Price: From $175

DSterling Harbor House Bed & Breakfast

Average Rating
4.5
3+ reviews
from 2 sources
CitySearch
3.5
1+ reviews
BedAndBreakfast.com
5.0
2+ reviews
  • we stayed in the captain's suite and was treated to on of the most amazing views ... more on bedandbreakfast.com
  • Overview Summary :VillageWine country;Room_Rates :(USD American Dollars)All occupancy rates are subject to changeState and local taxes ... more on BedAndBreakfast.com
Sterling Harbor House Bed & Breakfast
125 Sterling Street
Greenport NY 11944, USA

Estimated Price: From $175

EStirling House Bed and Breakfast

Average Rating
4.0
4+ reviews
from 1 sources
tripadvisor
4.0
4+ reviews
  • it was nice getting out of the city to enjoy some fresh air and experience the nice town more on Tripadvisor
  • of the water but you can sit out on the porch and enjoy a summer night more on Tripadvisor
Stirling House Bed and Breakfast
143 Sterling Avenue
Greenport, NY 11944

Estimated Price: From $155

FStirling House Bed and Breakfast

  • Overview Description of Surrounding Area :Open year round and located in beautiful Greenport, New York on the North Fork of Long Island, the Stirling House Bed & Breakfast offers southern-style hospitality ... more on Real Adventures
Stirling House Bed and Breakfast
104 Bay Avenue
Greenport, New York, New York 11944, United States

Estimated Price: From $175